Slim v. Skinny Jeans: A Clarification

September 19, 2010 · 13 comments

in Apparel,Tips

From some of the questions I’ve been asked lately, it seems some of you gents are unsure of what’s considered “slim-fitting” versus “skinny”. When I say choose a slimmer-fitting pair of jeans you may imagine something like this:

Slim v. Skinny Jeans: Way-Too-Skinny Jeans

Don’t get it twisted. I don’t want men walking around in jeans like that, as I believe that degree of snugness should only be worn by the ladies.

In reality, I mean something along the lines of:

Slim v. Skinny Jeans: Slim fit jeans

Slim v. Skinny: It’s all marketing

You have to understand that these terms are generally used for marketing, and most of the time,  both “slim” and “skinny” are used interchangeably.

For example, the Levi’s 511 Skinny Fit or the 484 Slim Fit from J.Crew looks good on most men with a slimmer build and legs. They also tend to fit the same (as far as I could tell, seeing as though I couldn’t pull either of them past my rock-hard calves,) but one is called slim, the other, skinny.

For men such as myself with slightly bigger thighs and calves, the Levi’s 514 Slim Straight model provides that fitted look… whereas if you threw the 514s on a guy with a smaller build, it would look like a pair of baggy jeans.

For the truly muscular who are searching for that tailored appearance but can’t imagine squeezing into these previously-mentioned models (Tommy from TBTYH comes to mind), something like the Levi’s 501 may be your jam.

That make sense?

Ultimately, it’s all about fit.

Don’t be fooled by a brand’s naming conventions on their pants. Another example of inconsistency would be the Dockers D-1 “Slim Fit” khakis. Sure, they’re called slim fit, and if you compare it to their other models, they are relatively more slim. After trying them on myself, however, they’re not nearly as tailored as I prefer, and that’s coming from me, Mr. Buff Quads. You can imagine what they’d be like on a guy with a much slimmer build.

(Disclosure: After checking out the dockers.com site, seems there are various types of D-1 fits, and some appear slimmer than others, though I only tried the pair I linked to above, so I can’t say much regarding the other models.)

What’s a man to do?

Know your body type, familiarize yourself with the different cuts of pants by trying a variety on, and find a pair that suits you best. You don’t want anything too tight or restrictive, but you do want a pair that appears tailored and lacks the extra unnecessary material that gives off a baggy appearance.

What are your sticking points when it comes to buying jeans or pants? Do you have trouble honing in on your best fit? Let me know.


About

Barron is the founder and editor of Effortless Gent, a site dedicated to helping dudes figure out what looks best on them. He also co-founded Fifth&Brannan, a menswear label based in San Francisco. Connect with him on Twitter and Facebook.

  • Jfkjean

    When your jeans are holding on for dear life as they are in photo number one, man or woman, skinny or not, they should be moving on to another fit/size but good post nonetheless.

  • http://effortlessgent.com Barron

    Haha, I do agree, though if faced with the choice, I prefer to see the snugness of image one on a lady, versus a dude. :)

  • http://twitter.com/TBTYH Tommy V.

    Hey man, thanks for the mention.

    One thing I’d like to add as well for anyone with more massive thighs/rear: pay attention to the rise measurement too. If you have a bigger butt, you’ll need a bigger rise. Often times these slim/skinny fit pants and jeans have single-digit inch rises (which personally does not work well at all for me).

  • Bryan

    Hey, Barron, I noticed your site from Joe’s mention on dappered.com and decided to stop by. So far I like what I see.

    I recently tried the Dockers D-1, and agree with your assessment: not slim at all (from what I am used to)! While I have a little bit of quad muscle, as I started biking regularly this summer, I am overall mostly “slim”, with a little bit of the broad shoulder thing happening. To that end I have been looking for some slimmer chinos/khakis, and for a while have been a big fan of the J.Crew Urban Slim fit. Only problem is they are kind of lacking in color options, and their in-store featured “broken in” line is a bit too casual for work at times.

    Since you appear to have the same fit taste as I do, judging by your review of the D-1′s, do you recommend any alternatives to the Urban Slim Fit? I’m talking chinos/khakis, more than jeans. I am well aware of the Levi 511/514 on the jean side.

    Thanks!

  • Zuriel

    good point! A lesson that some folks havent learned yet.

  • Zuriel

    good point! A lesson that some folks havent learned yet.

  • Zuriel

    good point! A lesson that some folks havent learned yet.

  • http://effortlessgent.com Barron

    Hey Bryan,

    Thanks for stopping by! Glad to hear I’m not the only one a little confused by the fit of those D-1 khakis. I was disappointed mostly because they have some great colors in stock, but if the fit isn’t right, it’s just not worth buying, obviously.

    I like the urban slim fit as well, and it is hard finding other comparable fits with more color choices. I know Rugby has these chinos (http://bit.ly/cDpsEK) that look like a great fit, but I haven’t tried them myself, so I can’t say for sure. Also, Bonobos has a great selection of chinos. I love their straight legs and the fit is pretty great. I have a pair of these (http://bit.ly/dldTsv). Their pants are worth checking out, for sure.

    Good luck, and let me know what you find!

  • http://effortlessgent.com Barron

    Thanks Zuriel!

  • http://effortlessgent.com Barron

    Tommy,

    Definitely glad you mentioned rise. Bit of an oversight, though I should’ve pointed that out.

    Listen up, kids: If you do have bigger thighs / butt and are trying to squeeze into a pair of jeans with a rise too low, you’re gonna feel like you’re sagging, but you’ll also have no more pant to pull up. Quite the predicament. Find a pair with a higher rise! Your butt will thank you.

    Thanks for the pointing that out man.

  • Jonathan Cyr

    I have huge quads, should I just stick with straight fit?

  • http://effortlessgent.com Barron

    Hey Jonathan,

    Depends. How comfortable are straight legs when you put em on?

    I know Levis 505 and 501 have more room in the thigh area without having to resort to an all-over loose fit. Give those a try and see if they’re any better than your typical (slimmer) straight leg.

  • http://profiles.google.com/kobebb2011 paul kobe

    Only problem is they are kind of lacking in color options.
    http://www.menjeansonline.com/

Previous post:

Next post: